Bruce Oyler, Computational Systems, Inc., Knoxville,
Tennessee
Personal well-being and plant profitability have some things in common.
The more we know ourselves, the easier we find our way in life.
When we have a handle on our financial obligation in the near future,
we sleep easily. At work, the same element of understanding applies. But
too often, a lack of knowledge and control leads to lost profits. In the
plant maintenance arena, we frequently see companies with no game plan.
In an economic climate of flexible manufacturing reliable equipment performance
is vital.
Predictive maintenance helps businesses know themselves. Armed with
knowledge about their equipment, they can control cost, quality, and delivery.
A sound reliability-based maintenance plan not only detects and confirms
machinery problems, but diagnoses their root cause to correct it once and
for all. That translates into millions of dollars in savings for discrete
manufacturing industries.
Machines run more efficiently with tighter tolerances, for instance.
The result is less scrap and waste and better quality. Rough-running machinery
often produces an inconsistent product, whether in size or finish variations.
There's more at stake than money. For components that are manufactured
for power aircraft or automobiles, quality becomes an issue of safety and
reputation.
As the first step, discrete manufactures
need a system and equipment reliability and prioritization plan.
Predictive programs
The predictive maintenance programs at many discrete batch plants,
particularly smaller ones, run on a catch-as-catch-can basis--when budget
and time permits. A number of companies use their equipment for troubleshooting
rather than organized trend-monitoring. Understandably, at a small company
the cost of equipment and training may not be justified so an outside contractor
comes in periodically to monitor the health of the machinery.
Whomever is responsible, whether in-house staff or consulting team,
wants to determine where deterioration may occur well in advance and appropriately
plan for repairs that actually will be needed.
Some plants tear down and inspect every 30, 60, or 90 days. However,
that practice does not take into account the individual nature of an operation,
such as the percent of the time machines are running or other operating
conditions. It's like changing the car oil every three months because the
manufacturer says to do so, not because of the conditions the vehicle has
endured.
System and equipment reliability plan
As the first step, discrete manufacturers need a system and equipment
reliability and prioritization plan. This is a way to rank the importance
of different pieces of machinery in the plant to achieve maximum reliability.
The significance of systems and equipment to the overall process is
based on function, cost, production, safety, quality, and other concerns.
If a main transformer went down, for example, that would be critical. But
if a bathroom fan blew, well, who would care?
Among the benefits of such a survey is the tailoring of preventive maintenance
activities to ensure an appropriate level of service. The goal, of course,
is to keep machinery in excellent condition, but not to overmaintain it.
The results of such a system and equipment reliability plan include:
-
system definition and ranking of systems by element,
-
equipment assignment and ranking,
-
critical equipment list,
-
maintenance priority for critical equipment,
-
failure modes and effects analysis for critical equipment,
-
maintenance task analysis for critical equipment,
-
maintenance priority for noncritical equipment, and
-
maintenance task reviews for noncritical equipment.
In the evaluation, maintenance experts want to review previous patterns
of machinery problems.
What happens most often? Are the common problems misalignment, imbalance
and bearing wear or gear-tooth grinding and rotor rub?
Then they look at plausible functional failures: the possible modes,
underlying causes, and the consequences. After checking the equipment,
failure modes, and effects the next step is drawing a defense plan. This
encompasses the most cost-effective mix of maintenance tools and services.
The goal is to assign tasks that mitigate, warn, or defend against failure
in appropriate ways.
Our philosophy is to use nonintrusive techniques and technologies wherever
possible. We try to keep preventive maintenance to a minimum. This helps
reduce lost production and associated costs. A business ideally knows in
advance when major maintenance is needed. This is especially important
in the era of just-in-time production, when precious dollars ride on every
minute of available production time.
Finally, continue system and equipment reliability planning with noncritical
machines. To make the process more manageable, try taking the equipment
list in bits--say, 20 percent at a time--until all systems are go.
Just in time
Until recently, companies often stocked large inventories, but tying
up capital that way is no longer common. Instead, businesses depend on
just-in-time inventory. Companies that can respond command the road.
They dispatch products to customers just in time to meet their needs.
If the shipment arrives late, a whole factory of people may not have anything
to do. That's where predictive maintenance comes in.
Many automobile manufacturers require their vendors to have predictive
maintenance plans in place. They gain a feeling of comfort that supply
needs will be met just in time. For those who can pull it off, just-in-time
delivery saves untold millions. But the time constraints leave little room
for failure. For instance, for a car to be manufactured at noon, the parts
need to arrive at a certain time just before that.
Dependable equipment allows vendors to hit the right delivery hour.
If the machinery isn't running properly and the product doesn't come through
on time, an angry customer may have a few words to say about reliability.
Manufacturers that use predictive maintenance to stay on track often
have smart monitors that serve as the first defense against machine problems.
The monitors, that track the operating and cumulative effects of parameters
such as load, number of starts, temperature, and vibration, act as burglar
alarms. They warn against potential hazards and help maintenance professionals
decide where to investigate further with a full diagnostic analysis. Smart
monitors help just-in-time manufacturers in many ways, including:
-
extending motor life.
-
estimating motor aging.
-
providing accurate motor condition assessment.
Again, it comes down to knowledge of an operation and its needs. Smart
people understand their equipment, how it works together, and which practices
maintain it best.
A good reliability-based
maintenance plan
not only detects and confirms
machinery problems,
but diagnoses their root
cause to correct it once and for all.
Predictive maintenance helps
businesses know themselves.
Selecting the best equipment
What is the right monitoring technology to buy? How much data to collect?
The answer to both questions is the same: It depends.
Refer back to the system equipment reliability prioritization plan.
Which are the most critical pieces of machinery to the operation? How much
work do you expect from your equipment? What are the failure rates and
modes?
After ranking equipment in priority of its effect on production and
understanding what can go wrong, learn what practices can help prevent
failure. Then find a supplier that can meet as many of those needs as possible.
The mix may include vibration analysis, oil analysis, infrared thermography,
motor diagnostics, and laser alignment and balancing. It's a good idea
to seek multiple technologies from a common supplier to help ensure continuity
in product, service and training. quality assurance
As the name implies, predictive maintenance helps predict when and where
deterioration will occur. Advance knowledge can head off problems which
cause waste and cost time.
It costs considerably less time and money to ensure that a pump or gearbox
is properly lubricated than it does to replace the lubricant. Ideally your
company will strike a good balance of predictive, preventive, and proactive
maintenance to ensure the highest quality possible in the end product.
These are not programs, but rather, a style of maintenance that spells
care and concern for the customer and marketplace.
Copyright October 1997 Plant Services on the WEB
|